Price: $12 * Size: 2.4 g * Buy At: Starlook's Website http://starlooks.com/collections/eyes/products/kohl-eye-pencil
The Starlooks Khol Eye Pencil in Obsidian is a matte black eye liner that is designed to "glide across delicate lids without pulling". This liner came in my September Ipsy Bag.
This eyeliner is fairly smooth, but it is not the creamiest liner I have come across. Sadly, this liner does tug on the lids, even though Starlooks claims that they glide without pulling. The shade Obsidian isn't the most intense black, but that can be good for a softer eyeliner look. For some reason, this liner would not apply to my water line. I kept moving the pencil back and forth and no liner came off onto my waterline or tightline.
In the swatches, the first line is created with the tip of the liner and is just one "swipe". The line in the middle is a built up color and the line on the right is a built up wavy line.
Unfortunately, this liner was definitely not smudge-proof. I let the swatch set for two or three minutes and it smudged everywhere when I rubbed the liner with my finger, and I didn't even rub that hard. This is very disappointing and there are so many great drugstore eyeliners that are cheaper than this one and work amazingly! (Although, I would like to point out that this is a khol liner which can be smudged out for a smokey look, so if that's what you are wanting a black liner for, then this may be for you!)