Price: $3.99 * Buy At: Ulta * Size: 0.14 oz / 4 g
Over the past year, I have bought twelve shades of the Nyx Extra Creamy Round Lipstick, and thought it would be helpful to swatch and compare all the shades. If you are unfamiliar with the Nyx Extra Creamy Round Lipsticks, they are very creamy and pigmented, but do not have the longest wear, which is understandable with the cheap price tag.
The lightest shades I have are Strawberry Milk ad Narcissus. Both are light, cool-toned pinks with a cream finish. Strawberry Milk is lighter than Narcissus and honestly, it's a hard color to pull off. The next three, Stella, Margarita and Haute Melon appear similar when swatched, but I wouldn't really call them dupes for each other. Stella is a bright yellow-based pink with a cream finish. Margarita is similar in color, but it has more of an orange-red tint and it has a frost finish. Haute Melon also has a cream finish, but is a bright orange-red. You can better see what Haute Melon looks like in my review HERE.
The next shades are all peachy, but quite different. Pure Nude is a peachy pink nude with a cream finish, Indian Pink is a peachy neutral pink with a pearly/frosty finish and Pumpkin Pie is a peachy brown nude with a cream finish.
The last four shades are all quite similar. I'd say that Tea Rose differs the most, because it is darker and a little more on the neutral side than the other colors. Blush is a neutral rose color with a cream finish. Paparazzi is quite close to Blush, but, Paparazzi is missing the reddish tint that Blush has. Fig is darker than Blush and Paparazzi and is a little more pink. All four shades have a cream finish.